On Dec 19, 2011, at 6:41 AM, Jamie Taylor wrote:
> all you want is a stronger similar, surely
> a medicinal agent should be made and then proved, not prove the
> individual parts and then mix it and expect the same materia medica
Actually I'm not the best person to argue this part, because I have
never been either a user or a prescriber of combos! (Well, other than
a first encounter with an EAV prescriber, but that doesn't even really
count.) However, from the years of hearing of other people's (casual
but sometimes satisfying) encounters with off-the-shelf combos, plus
the fact that one of my (very classical) teachers had stated that her
introduction to homeopathy was via combos and cell salts, I will say
that they can be useful -- and I would specify for acute, self-
limiting conditions, as a comfort aid and to apparently help speed the
cure.
Which again is a separate issue: whether they can be useful, or
Whether they are "homeopathy."
> On an external perspective water and ouzo are clear to our sight,
> but when in combo they together appear as opaque. so any
> prescription according to their individual characteristics does not
> exist in combination. So ......
> Combos are not in line with Hahnemann's homeopathy, call it
> something else and stop borrowing credibilty by using the authority
> of homeopathy!!
> Jamie
_______________________________________________
Homeopathy Mailing List
homeopathy@homeolist.com
http://lists.homeolist.com/mailman/listinfo/homeopathy
Keine Kommentare:
Kommentar veröffentlichen