Re: [H] Did homeopathy kill Steve Jobs, founder of Apple

On Dec 19, 2011, at 7:20 AM, John Harvey wrote:

> Jamie, the "match" Shannon is talking about is no more than a single
> symptom in common!

Argh, YOU keep saying that; I never did.
Again that is entirely separate from the question of combos per se.
So if "bland white discharge" is included on the label (which it
sometimes is) and in the pathogenesis of each chosen remedy, does that
make you any happier?
I thought not...

And if mental state is also included, would that?
I thought not.

Your issue is that any combination falls outside the realm of
"homeopathy." Correct?
Then why keep muddying the issue?
At least let's take them *one at a time*!

> It's no match; simply a passing coincidence.

And why keep broadening the scattershot range with unnecessary side-
factors, especially when they are so obviously not true? How on earth
can you call if "coincidence", when you have previously been calling
it "single symptom"? That is superficial yes, but it is not
coincidence.

Precision, please!

This is part of why I find these discussions with you so frustrating.
There's enough to deal with if we stick to the *actual* issues, or
even the central ones, without grabbing every red herring that swims
thru your mental process!!

Argh...
Shannon

>
> I said nothing about Hering, and have seen no reference to him. And
> I seem
> to have received your message directly from you but not also from
> the list.
> So perhaps my subscription has gone awry. Or are you posting
> directly to
> the otherhealth web site?
>
> Cheers --
>
> John
>
>
>
> On 20 December 2011 00:15, Jamie Taylor
> <jamie.taylor@theleaffoundation.org>wrote:
>
>> Sorry, I had no idea that combos had been proved, I thought only the
>> individual parts had been proved, but as stated that is no guide as
>> to the
>> MM of the parts in combination
>> Please direct me to the provings of the combos as a unit and as
>> sold, I
>> look forward to studying their pathogenesis, assuming the provings
>> are
>> trustworthy!!
>> Happy Christmas everyone
>> With best wishes from
>>
>> Jamie
>>
>> PS John, had no idea about the theatrical story of Herings depression
>> (what was the play?!)
>>
>>
>>
>> On 19/12/2011 12:55, Shannon Nelson wrote:
>>
>>>
>>> On Dec 19, 2011, at 6:34 AM, Jamie Taylor wrote:
>>>
>>> How can you prescribe something of which you have no idea what its
>>>> pathogenesis is?
>>>>
>>>
>>> Jamie, who has done or advocated that?
>>> Even in the rankest of combo usage, there is a match being
>>> considered
>>> between pathogenesis (aka "the remedy picture") and the case at
>>> hand.
>>>
>>>
>>>
>>>
>
>
> --
>
>
> "And if care became the ethical basis of citizenship? Our
> parliaments,
> guided by such ideas, would be very different places."
>
>
> —Paul Ginsborg, *Democracy: Crisis and Renewal*, London: Profile,
> 2008.
> _______________________________________________
> Homeopathy Mailing List
> homeopathy@homeolist.com
> http://lists.homeolist.com/mailman/listinfo/homeopathy

_______________________________________________
Homeopathy Mailing List
homeopathy@homeolist.com
http://lists.homeolist.com/mailman/listinfo/homeopathy